Denny’s Sub Shop Menu

Denny’s Sub Shop in Big Flats, NY, offers a heartfelt tribute to classic, homemade subs that feel like a warm embrace from a small-town favorite. Every sandwich is crafted with fresh, daily-baked bread that has earned raves for its exceptional quality and flavor, often stealing the show. The meatballs are famously gigantic and bursting with rich taste, making each hero a satisfying experience. Beyond the subs, Denny’s shakes and pizzas promise equally memorable flavors, embodying a true delight for comfort food lovers.

What stands out is the genuine hospitality—the friendly owners and personal touches create a welcoming, cozy vibe. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or packing a picnic, the shop caters thoughtfully to your needs, offering customized options with care. Denny’s Sub Shop is more than a deli; it’s a nostalgic culinary haven, preserving timeless flavors with fresh ingredients and honesty. This place captures the charm of old-school eateries where quality, warmth, and community come first.

Cold Subs

Regular

Ham & Cheese

Roast Beef

Italian

Turkey & Cheese

Tuna

Cheese W/Veggies

Ham, Turkey, Cheese

Ham, Pepperoni, Cheese

Pastrami & Swiss

Beef & Swiss

Chicken Patty W/ Swiss

Dressed Cold Subs W/ Heated

Salads

Tuna

Garden

Chef

Canned Soda

Milkshakes

Floats

Ibc Rootbeer, Cr. Soda

Snapple

Cold Tea

Water

Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

Drinks

Hot Subs

Bbq Roast Beef

Super Roast Beef Lettuce & P & O

Ham & Cheese

Dressed Ham And Cheese

Bbq Ham, Cheese, Onions

Hot Sausage W/P&O

Homemade Meatball

Pepperoni And Cheese

Pizza

Chicken Parmesan

Pastrami & Cheese

Ibc Rootbeer

Others